← All calls
ElectionActive

ME Senate — Collins retention

Will Susan Collins (R) retain her Maine Senate seat in 2026?

EHIQ
50%
(42-58%)
Polymarket
live market →
Edge

Thesis

Collins won 2020 comfortably; moderate R brand in ME real. Emerson Mar 21-23 2026 poll has Platner (D) +7 vs Collins (48-41). ME blue-leaning + Trump-era D enthusiasm could catalyze a strong D challenger; Mills withdrew, clearing path to Platner. SEM v1.2 structural anchor 25.34%; Polymarket Republican ~27%. EHIQ at 50% — wide range 42-58% reflecting genuine uncertainty + significant downward revision from prior 62%.
  1. 1.PROBABILITY REVISION TIMESTAMPED 2026-05-22: EHIQ 62% → 50% after SEM v1.2 build + TIQ 2026-05-22 re-scoring. **LARGEST REVISION IN THIS UPDATE — FLAG FOR ERIC REVIEW.** SEM v1.2 me-senate-general probability = 25.34% (v1.1 was 25.43%; v1.2 mechanisms did not fire). Polymarket "Maine Senate Election Winner" — Republican (Collins) ~27% (per SEM provenance). Apples-to-apples gap: SEM-EHIQ = -36.7pp; Market-EHIQ = -35pp. BOTH disagree materially with prior 62%. Underlying poll Emerson Mar 21-23 2026 (n=1,075, MOE ±2.9pp): Platner 48 / Collins 41. Mills withdrew clearing D path to Platner. TIQ specificity Collins 30.59 (HIGH_CONVICTION per 2026-05-22 scoring) directly contradicts the prior EHIQ thesis claim of "highest desperation signal" — TIQ reads HIGH conviction (not weakness). §4 OOS Phase C FAIL (ρ=+0.18, p=0.35) prohibits claiming TIQ is method-validated, but the prior "desperation" reading was itself TIQ-research-internal. Conservative damping: not converged to SEM 25%/market 27% — preserved at 50% to acknowledge (a) Collins-specific moderate-R brand strength in ME, (b) Emerson poll is 2 months stale, (c) Dem primary 2026-06-09 still pending. Range 42-58% to reflect the material uncertainty band.
Opened
April 19, 2026
Expected resolution
November 4, 2026