← All calls
LegalResolvedNOT SCORED★ featured
Trump v. Cook (No. 25A312) — can the President fire a Fed Governor without cause?
Will the Supreme Court allow President Trump to remove Federal Reserve Governor Lisa Cook without cause?
premise not yet verified
EHIQ
Not graded
last stored figure 30% (not graded)
Market
—
gap vs market
—
—
Thesis
We expect the Court to split the removal-power question rather than decide it as one. The companion FTC case (Slaughter) looks set to let the President fire an agency commissioner and narrow Humphrey's Executor — but we expect the Court to carve out the Federal Reserve as structurally distinct and preserve it from at-will removal. At argument the justices signaled sympathy to Cook, and a ruling that let a President fire a Fed governor at will would be read by markets as the end of central-bank independence — an outcome a majority appears unwilling to author. Most coverage prices the two cases as one removal question; we price them as a deliberate split. There is no clean market on the Cook outcome, which is exactly where the mispricing sits.
- 1.We read the removal-power cases as a split, not a single outcome: the FTC firing (Slaughter) likely stands while the Fed (Cook) is walled off.
- 2.Argument coverage showed justices sympathetic to Cook; a majority appears unwilling to author the end of at-will Fed independence.
- 3.The term shows a two-sided pattern — the Court checked executive overreach on the tariff/IEEPA question (6-3) while upholding immigration enforcement (Mullin) — consistent with shielding a structurally unique Fed here.
- 4.No clean prediction market exists on the Cook outcome; the indirect 'Cook out' contracts conflate it with the FTC question.
Resolution
Outcome
NO
Resolved
June 29, 2026
We put 30% on the Court ALLOWING removal — it blocked it 5-4, so our lean (Cook stays) was correct.
Opened
June 27, 2026
Expected resolution
July 1, 2026
Get an alert the moment this call resolves.
Each published EHIQ call carries a resolution date; when it resolves, the verdict is posted here. Subscribe free and we email you when this one grades, plus the weekly divergence leaderboard.